OTTAWA – NetNewsLedger Politics 2.0 – As Prime Minister Mark Carney continues to govern from the right of the political spectrum in Canadian policy, Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre remains notably absent from the House of Commons, awaiting a deferred by-election.
This gap is shaping both his party’s influence and public perception ahead of the next election.
The Conservatives are left basically forced in many cases to agree with the Liberals but demand that they move even further to the right. If the Liberals listened, all that would accomplish is to leave less room for the Conservatives on the political debate.
Conservative Leader Poilievre’s Seat Loss Haunts the Opposition
In the April 2025 federal election, Poilievre suffered a double blow: his party held its ground, even gaining seats, but he lost his Carleton riding, marking a major political setback. The Conservatives retained momentum—adding roughly 2.5 million votes and 25 seats, their strongest showing since 1988.
Yet without a seat, Poilievre cannot respond directly to Carney’s pivots, debate in question period, or really rally the troops in Parliament. Technically he is simply a visitor at the House of Commons. His media presence has shrunk, and ironically despite having a massive social media presence, the Conservative leader is mainly silent there too.
MP Damien Kurek has vacated his Battle River–Crowfoot seat, paving the way for Poilievre’s anticipated return via by-election. Officially triggered in mid-June, a writ may drop anytime before June 29, with the earliest by-election on August 4. In the meantime, former leader Andrew Scheer serves as interim Opposition leader.
Public Opinion: Liberals Maintain Edge
The most recent polling indicates Carney—and the Liberals—continue to hold a modest but steady lead. A national Abacus Data survey from June 17–19 shows 52% approval for the Carney government, with 28% disapproval. While public sentiment remains cautiously optimistic, Carney hasn’t yet converted that goodwill into a dominant polling advantage—and it hasn’t closed enough ground for the Conservatives.
The Liberals are fundraising like crazy, working to build up an election war chest toward the next election which in a minority parliament could come at any time. The Conservatives and New Democrats both without a leader elected and sitting in the House of Commons are continuing to lag in both public and media presence.
A separate tracking poll showed rapid gains in country optimism and Liberal leadership favorability, reinforcing Carney’s apparent advantage . Meanwhile, national preferences narrow: Conservatives stand around 38–39%, versus 41–42% for the Liberals . Notably, 36% of Canadians consider Poilievre the best prime ministerial option, trailing Carney’s 41%.
Carney’s Strategy: Shifting Right, Strategic Advantage
Despite his centrist image, Carney has adopted a more assertive posture. He has kept public spending in check, strengthened fiscal frames, and reinforced Canada’s stance against U.S. threats—all moves aligned with conservative framing without alienating centrist voters. Analysts credit Carney’s positioning for neutralizing Poilievre’s “axe the tax” strategy and undercutting Trump-esque populism.
Conservatives: Credibility Without a Leader in the House?
Poilievre’s absence from Parliament complicates the Conservative narrative. Without his presence in Ottawa, the party is relying on media, public appearances, and surrogate MPs—but lacks the immediate impact of parliamentary scrutiny.
Analyst David Coletto warns that this structural gap could erode momentum, noting Carney’s success in consolidating anti-Trump sentiment and expanding Liberal fortunes in swing regions .
However, Poilievre remains formidable on the ground, buoyed by strong base support and the 2025 Election results. His comeback narrative however hinges on confirming that Battle River–Crowfoot seat, but critics warn of a dangerous leaderless stretch in Parliament.
The Road Ahead: Key Variables in 2025–26
-
By-Election Timing & Outcome – A successful run in August could quickly restore Poilievre’s parliamentary and rhetorical presence.
-
Carney’s Continued Drift Right – How far the Liberals can go without alienating their centre base.
-
Poll Shifts – Any softening in public approval of Carney or a rise in Conservative support may be decisive, especially if Poilievre returns too late.
-
Geopolitical Context – Rising U.S. tensions or economic uncertainty could swing sentiment toward a stronger Opposition.
Conclusions
Poilievre remains a potent figure in Conservative politics, but his inability to occupy a Commons seat has muted his influence during a pivotal period.
It is difficult to understand how the Conservatives failed to see their leader’s problems in the riding, and their failure to move into action soon enough to prevent the election defeat.
Prime Minister Carney’s calibrated rightward moves and solid public ratings have further constrained conventional Conservative attacks.
The upcoming by-election may redefine the dynamic: a triumphant return could relaunch Poilievre’s influence, while even a narrow victory may not offset the momentum Carney has-earned in public and parliamentary spheres.
