Ontario Paying the Price for Rush on HST?


THUNDER BAY – It is becoming increasingly obvious that the claims made by the Ontario Progressive Conservatives on the Ontario HST being rushed through without fully making sure that the right direction was being taken have merit.

On April 30th, in the Brockville news, the paper quotes a Ministry of Revenue official on the HST. “They’ve rushed this . . . Generally it takes us five years to decide which envelopes we’re going to buy, and they rushed this in one year” – Ministry of Revenue Official Jim Gordon on the McGuinty Government’s HST plan.

Today the McGuinty Government is basically admitting there are still problems with the tax. Yet they are placing the blame on the federal government rather than taking responsibilityfor the issue themselves. “We already know the HST tax grab will drive up the cost of gas, hydro, home heating fuel and dozens of other goods and services we use every day, and there still could be a few more surprises up Dalton McGuinty’s sleeve,” charges Tim Hudak, Leader of the Ontario PCs.

Ontario has entered into an agreement with First Nations to protect treaty rights over the right of Aboriginals to be exempt from the provincial sales tax. First Nations in Ontario, represented by the Political Confederacy, and the Government of Ontario represented by Minister of Aboriginal Affairs Chris Bentley and Minister of Revenue John Wilkinson have entered into a Memorandum of Agreement. The agreement commits the parties to work together to realize the continuation of the First Nation point of sale tax exemption within the framework of the Harmonized Sales Tax (HST), which is set to come into effect on July 1, 2010.

“This agreement demonstrates our commitment to working with Ontario’s First Nations to safeguard the current point of sale exemptions under the new HST. We realize this is a vital issue for First Nations people and we will continue in our efforts to secure a federally approved and administered tax exemption,” stated Chris Bentley
Minister of Aboriginal Affairs.

Currently, First Nations in Ontario who are status Indians receive a point of sale tax exemption under the retail sales tax on the purchase of goods both on and off-reserve. However, because the HST will be administered by the federal government, unless something is done First Nations stand to lose the point of sale exemption for the purchase of goods off reserve. The federal government administers the HST in the same way they administer the Goods and Services Tax (GST), which means that off-reserve purchases of goods will only be exempt if they are delivered to the reserve by the vendor or the vendor’s agent.

The Government of Ontario supports the First Nations in Ontario with respect to continuing the current First Nation point of sale tax exemption under the HST framework. Ontario has committed to work shoulder to shoulder with First Nations to realize this objective and to engage the federal government to accept the point of sale exemption. The joint work will also include First Nations and the Ontario government working together to address the concerns raised by the federal government relating to data and accounting requirements necessary for the administration of the HST.

“The Memorandum of Agreement signed today is a positive step toward achieving our objective to ensure that the First Nations point of sale exemption continues under the HST framework. The Government of Ontario has committed to work with us to realize our priority — which is to ensure that we do not lose our point of sale exemption. We also want to ensure that First Nations people, many of whom struggle at or below the poverty line, are not impacted by the move to the HST,” stated Ontario Regional Chief Angus Toulouse.

Regional Chief Toulouse explained that this agreement is a step forward in the effort to preserve the point of sale exemption. The focus now shifts to the federal government to cooperate with First Nations and the Ontario government to work towards a resolution before July 1st. However, is they are not able to convince the federal government by July 1st, the agreement recognizes that interim relief may be necessary while the restoration of the point of sale exemption is being finalized.

The Memorandum of Agreement must be presented to the First Nations leadership in Ontario for ratification at a Chiefs Assembly at the earliest possible opportunity.

Previous articleCity of Thunder Bay Advises Residents on Issues
Next articleHydrogen Technology Marches on Without McGuinty
NetNewsledger.com or NNL offers news, information, opinions and positive ideas for Thunder Bay, Ontario, Northwestern Ontario and the world. NNL covers a large region of Ontario, but are also widely read around the country and the world. To reach us by email: newsroom@netnewsledger.com Reach the Newsroom: (807) 355-1862