Germany floods: Can we tell if extreme weather is linked to climate change?

Climate Change - Image:
Climate Change - Image:

As Germany and neighbouring countries face deadly floods, how much do we know about climate change’s role in extreme weather?

More than 100 people have died and at least 1,000 are missing following floods in Germany and Belgium that swept away buildings, cut phone communications and forced thousands to flee their homes.

The floods are the latest in an accelerating pattern of extreme weather around the world, with Canada and western U.S. states facing record-smashing high temperatures that have killed hundreds.

Even Siberia in Russia’s far north has been experiencing a heatwave and forest fires.

Climate experts say global warming is making weather extremes more likely and frequent.

But how much can we say about climate’s role in a specific weather event? Here’s what scientists had to say:


Can we know whether specific extreme weather events are driven by climate change?

Climate change is never the sole cause of an extreme weather event, but it can sometimes be a significant contributing factor, according to specialists.

“An event is the result of many drivers. There are many factors that influence and may favour an extreme event,” said Nikos Christidis, a senior scientist at Britain’s Met Office.

But global warming is making the world’s weather hotter and more volatile in general, making it more likely that extreme events take place, said Maarten van Aalst, director of the Red Cross Red Crescent Climate Centre.

Extreme events happen when climate change and natural weather variability come together – and may be influenced by other geographical factors, such as whether nearby rivers and lakes are empty enough to absorb water from heavy rains.

“The only way you can say if something is changing due to climate change is to say whether the odds of that really bad day are changing,” said van Aalst.

“There’s always an element of bad luck, but the chances of bad luck are increasing – quite rapidly in some cases.”


Can climate scientists calculate how much climate change influenced a particular weather event?

Researchers at the World Weather Attribution (WWA) project say they can confidently assess how much more likely climate change has made individual major weather events such as heatwaves, intense rains and storms.

They gather key data, such as temperature readings or rainwater measurements.

They compare them to historical trends for similar weather in the area, and run computer simulations that model expected weather norms both with and without climate change.

The process takes between a week and two months depending on the complexity, said Geert Jan van Oldenborgh, one of the leaders of the WWA initiative.

The project’s findings can be stark. For instance, the extreme heat that killed hundreds of people in the Pacific Northwest earlier this month would have been “virtually impossible” without global warming, they found.

What is the wider trend in climate-linked extreme weather?

While it is not possible to pin the full blame for any single event on a heating planet, the wider trend is clear, with experts pointing to increasingly volatile weather and a sharp rise in climate-linked disastersover recent decades.

Global warming can also bring a few benefits, with harmful extreme cold events reducing even as record heatwaves become more common, said van Oldenborgh.

On average, though, “the net balance is very damaging”, he said.

Why does knowing climate change’s role in extreme weather matter?

Understanding how a warming world is driving extremes and how those trends could develop in the future is vital to ensure we can adapt to coming conditions and try to reduce the risks, climate scientists said.

“These events are the wake-up calls that the world apparently needs,” said van Aalst.

With more people living in cities – many of them very vulnerable to floods, heatwaves, storms and other risks – the combination of strengthening climate change and growing populations in harm’s way needs more attention, he said.

“We’re setting ourselves up potentially for a double-whammy of rising climate risk, plus rising exposure and vulnerability,” he said. “But there’s also an opportunity there if we can increase awareness.”

Clear evidence of increasing risk can help unlock funding to curb threats and ensure officials create plans to protect their residents, said van Oldenborgh.

Evidence of climate risks also can help tackle scepticism among some people about the need to act on climate change, and drive wider action to reduce emissions.

“Showing that climate change is not some abstract thing in the future but is really affecting us right now helps to build support for mitigation – for reducing CO2 emissions,” he said.

“Of course, the big impacts will be in the future but showing there are already sizeable impacts now … makes it more concrete to people.”

Previous articleKamloops Indian Residential School missing children findings but a fraction of investigation and work needed
Next articleFloods lay bare Europe’s ‘gigantic task’ in averting future climate damage