Failure of Free Trade Talks with EU Could Hit Canada Hard

Prime Minister Trudeau
Prime Minister Trudeau
Canada's Liberal leader and Prime Minister-designate Justin Trudeau leaves at the conclusion of a news conference in Ottawa, Ontario, October 20, 2015. REUTERS/Chris Wattie
Canada’s Prime Minister-Justin Trudeau leaves at the conclusion of a news conference in Ottawa, Ontario, October 20, 2015. REUTERS/Chris Wattie

By David Ljunggren

OTTAWA (Reuters) – The looming failure of free trade talks with the European Union would derail Canada’s push to reduce its dependence on the United States and potentially complicate negotiations with other nations, such as India and China.

The EU’s hopes of signing the pact this week appeared to evaporate on Monday as the Belgian government failed to win the consent of regional authorities necessary to approve the deal.

The European deal would have given Canada preferential access to a market of 500 million people, more than the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), at a time when the U.S.-Canadian partnership is under pressure.

Canada sends 75 percent of all its exports to the United States.

“We are one of the most dependent countries in the world in regards to trade,” said former Quebec Premier Jean Charest, who initiated negotiations for the EU deal during his tenure.

“If this agreement fails, it will be a disappointment,” he told Reuters.

It would leave Canada, which is desperate to revive a sluggish export sector, in the predicament policymakers have tried to avoid: overly dependent on the United States, where both presidential candidates have talked about changing NAFTA.

Getting the Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA) through would be a coup for Prime Minister Justin Trudeau who has pressed other countries to resist protectionist sentiment since taking office in November.

With NAFTA under threat and a proposed 12-nation Pacific area trade deal on life support, Canadian officials pushed hard to try and overcome hurdles to CETA in various European states.

Along the way, however, Canada made concessions that could make it less attractive for future potential trading partners.

As opposition in Europe grew, Canada agreed to weaker investor protection rules to grant governments more power over overseas companies. Those new regulations would govern any future trade talks the country enters, the trade ministry said.


Increasing public backlash against globalisation, one of the main challenges for the EU deal, means none of the agreements Canada is working on could happen soon, said Carleton University trade policy professor Michael Hart.

The need to diversify exports was one of the reasons Trudeau vowed to boost trade with China and India. With CETA in doubt, there will be fresh impetus to press on with those deals.

One person close to the discussions, however, said Ottawa would struggle to speed up the pace of talks.

Discussions with India are going very slowly and there is no guarantee the negotiations will succeed, said two people familiar with the talks.

A source in India’s Commerce and Industry ministry said the talks were not expected to produce a decision in the near future due to differences over dispute settlement mechanisms. India also opposes the idea of having labour and environment standards included in the deal, the source added.

Meanwhile, Trudeau’s government is split over what concessions to make in talks with China, which wants Canada to ease curbs on investment in key sectors such as energy.

Opinion polls show most Canadians oppose the idea of a China agreement, which insiders say is at least a decade away.

The Trans-Pacific Partnership deal that Canada signed in February looks set to fall victim to political discord in the United States, killing off much-prized access to Japanese markets for Canadian beef.

“For trade policy people, it’s going to be a very long slow tedious slog for the future,” said Hart, a former long-time foreign ministry expert who advised on NAFTA.

Asked whether Canada would redouble efforts with China and India if the European deal died, Trade Minister Chrystia Freeland said her “absolute and relentless focus” this week would be on CETA.

One reason officials refuse to concede the deal’s collapse is that CETA, which backers say could boost bilateral trade by 20 percent, promises imminent and tangible benefits.

With a proposed deal between the EU and the United States at best years away, some U.S. firms close to the Canadian border might consider moving operations north to take advantage of European market access, said Jason Langrish, executive director of the Canada-Europe Roundtable for Business trade lobby.

“This is the last hope,” he said of CETA.

(With additional reporting by Allison Lampert in Montreal, Ethan Lou in Toronto and Manoj Kumar in New Delhi; Editing by Tomasz Janowski and Andrew Hay)

Previous articleSafer Trick or Treating Makes Halloween Better
Next articleCETA Package Faces Tough Path Forward or NNL offers news, information, opinions and positive ideas for Thunder Bay, Ontario, Northwestern Ontario and the world. NNL covers a large region of Ontario, but we are also widely read around the country and the world. To reach us by email: Reach the Newsroom: (807) 355-1862