THUNDER BAY – I’ve been enjoying our nice summer weather all right, but I often find it hard to relax with so many things going on in the riding, in Ottawa, and around the world. The big picture is never far from my mind which is why I’d like to offer some food for thought over the next few weeks on the current economic situation in Canada. It’s not looking pretty, but knowing what we are in for is half the way to winning the battle in my opinion.
I hope that the next 3 weeks’ worth of columns will prove to be a stimulating read as you relax on your porch, at the cottage, or on your couch as you try to beat the heat. Analysts have recently identified three distinct threats to our future prosperity and standard of living in Canada, and they are; a made in Canada housing bubble, a made in Canada personal debt bubble, and record federal and provincial deficits by our governments. For this week’s column I would like to tackle the housing bubble problem, with the others to follow over the next two weeks.
According to the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives (CCPA), a housing bubble emerges, “when housing prices increase more rapidly than inflation, household incomes, and economic growth. Several factors tend to contribute to the growth of a housing bubble: low mortgage rates, access to easy credit, net immigration and the stock of available housing.” All of these conditions have persisted in Canada for nearly half a decade, which has helped fuel economic growth but also created ripe conditions for a national housing bubble.
So how do you know when you are in a housing bubble? Well the short answer is that you have to look at the pricing of homes relative to our net incomes and history. When you factor in median incomes, the same historic range appears for housing prices. The CCPA has found that housing prices for 20 years, prior to 2000, stayed in a narrow range of between 3 and 4 times provincial annual median income. Today, however, housing prices adjusted for income are out of their historical range, costing between 4.7 and 11.3 times Canadians’ annual income depending on the local market. This ratio appears to be validated by information from the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC), which has reported that the price a new single detached home in May in Vancouver was $1,080,000, in Toronto it was $647,000, and in Thunder Bay it was $335,000. The numbers shrink slightly when you factor in re-sale homes but the emergence of a national housing bubble is becoming more apparent by the month.
The big problem isn’t having a housing bubble though; it is that it will almost inevitably burst. The difficulty arises when the market runs out of either potential buyers or potential buyers run out of credit to fuel the sales of homes and the continuous price increases. In such a situation, prices can only go down. Since a person’s or family’s net worth is often dependent upon the value of their largest asset, their homes in most cases, declining prices will almost always result in declining net worth which makes credit scarcer and more expensive to obtain. Also, when the price bubble finally bursts, as it did in the United States about three years ago, many families will discover that they are suddenly locked into a mortgage that is actually greater than the value of the home, a condition recently dubbed by some US financial analysts as being ‘under water.’
With a higher debt to asset ratio, it will be harder for consumers to gain access to affordable credit to spend on goods and services, which inevitably hurts our economic growth and the profitability of small and large business, which leads to job cuts, less potential home buyers, etc. In short, the bursting of a housing bubble is often the start of a vicious economic cycle that becomes very difficult to recover from as is evidenced by the painful experience of our neighbours to the south.
Next week, we will look at the similar emergence of a debt bubble, and how it could dovetail with a housing bubble to create some very rough economic times over the next several years.
John Rafferty MP
Thunder Bay Rainy River
Week of July 8 – July 15, 2011
Much of the data and information in this week’s column was taken from some good sources which have much to offer if you wish to read up on the issue further. To read more from these sources please visit: Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation – “Housing Market Outlook – Major Urban Centres”
Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives – “Canada’s Housing Bubble: An Accident Waiting to Happen.”