Thunder Bay police arrested two men at a Main Street business. Read the allegations, charges and maximum penalties under Canada’s Criminal Code
Thunder Bay police say a retail-theft investigation led to one arrest, while officers encountered a second suspect at the same business
THUNDER BAY – NEWS – Two men have been remanded in custody after Thunder Bay Police Service officers made separate shoplifting arrests at a Main Street business on Monday, October 26, 2026.
In an October 27 release, police said several reports of thefts at the business throughout October prompted an investigation by the Break, Enter and Armed Robbery (BEAR) Unit.
Investigators reviewed surveillance footage from the reported incidents and identified a suspect, police said.
BEAR Unit officers were nearby shortly after noon on October 26 when the suspect allegedly attempted another theft. Officers arrested him and took him into custody.
Harley Jason Wittig, 49, is charged with:
- Theft under $5,000 — eight counts
- Failure to comply with a probation order — eight counts
While at the same location, officers allegedly saw a second man attempting to steal merchandise. Police said the man tried to run away when officers approached but was caught and arrested.
According to police, the second accused had outstanding warrants and was subject to a judicial release order prohibiting him from attending the business.
Darrell William McDonnell, 51, is charged with:
- Theft under $5,000
- Resist police
- Failure to comply with a release order
Police said both men were remanded in custody following initial court appearances.
The charges involve four offences under Canada’s Criminal Code. Each can be prosecuted by indictment or through the summary conviction process. The explanation below lists the maximum prison term per count when the Crown proceeds by indictment.
| Charge | What the offence involves | Maximum imprisonment on indictment |
|---|---|---|
| Theft under $5,000 | Dishonestly taking or converting property worth $5,000 or less, without a lawful claim, intending to deprive its owner of it. Sections 322 and 334(b) apply. | Two years. |
| Failure to comply with a probation order | Failing or refusing to follow a probation order without a reasonable excuse, under section 733.1. | Four years. |
| Resist police | Resisting or deliberately obstructing a police officer who is lawfully carrying out their duties, under section 129(a). | Two years. |
| Failure to comply with a release order | Failing, without a lawful excuse, to follow a condition of a judicial release order, under section 145(5). | Two years. |
If the Crown proceeds by summary conviction, each of these offences carries a general maximum of two years less a day in jail, a fine of up to $5,000, or both, under section 787. The police release did not indicate how prosecutors would proceed.
These maximums are not automatic sentences. Multiple charges also do not mean the maximum penalties will simply be added together. If convictions result, the court must consider the circumstances of the offences and the offender, and ensure any combined consecutive sentence is not unduly long or harsh.
The allegations have not been proven in court. Both accused are presumed innocent unless proven guilty.
Police file numbers: TB26043121 and TB26043130










