Guest Opinion – Pay to Slay is Not the Way!

Guest Editorial

The views, opinions and positions expressed by all Troy Media columnists and contributors are the author's alone. They do not inherently or expressly reflect the views, opinions and/or positions of Troy Media.

THUNDER BAY – Guest Column – It’s easy to believe in a world of simplicity, where being “open for business” trumps all else.  We all have to deal with complexity in our lives, with nuance, with ambiguity.  We all want to live in a world where human livelihoods and nature can coexist.  We know that’s important when, in this very week, the UN issued a devastating report. It demonstrates that extinctions of organisms are now occurring at rates “tens to hundreds of times higher than the average over the last 10 million years”. As many as a million species are at risk of disappearing in the next few decades – About an eighth of all Earth’s life forms. For a summary, see: https://www.popsci.com/un-extinction-report-stats-climate#page-2.

However, just last month Ontario’s government announced its intention to gut the province’s Endangered Species Act (ESA). The provisions include: allowing developers to pay into a fund rather than do what is necessary to ensure the survival of an endangered species on a site; allowing sweeping authorizations for developers to undertake harmful activities in multiple locations; removing the requirement of the Minister to consult scientific experts on endangered species; allowing the appointment of non-scientists to the technical panel on endangered species conservation (COSSARO); allowing the minister to ask COSSARO to reconsider its recommendations on an arbitrary basis and on… and….. on. A commentary by Ontario Nature can be found at https://ontarionature.org/endangered-species-act-review-top-ten/.

The public has been granted only until May 18thto comment on these drastic changes, using the Environmental Registry of Ontario (ERO). The four separate ERO numbers on this topic in the Registry make the process more difficult and confusing for ordinary folk (perhaps that is the government’s intention?).

The Quetico Foundation has championed the needs of Quetico Provincial Park and other natural features in NW Ontario for 65 years.  We know that the welfare of nature, of tourism, of Indigenous communities, and most important, of all our children and grandchildren, depends on maintaining healthy natural environments. The ESA is a critical component in that balance. Don’t let anybody fool you that you must let go of ecological integrity to make a buck now. It just isn’t true!

Please make your views on the ESA known now through the Environmental Registry. The proposed changes on the Endangered Species Act are open for public comment until May 18, 2019, this file #013-5033 can be found on the Environmental Registry at https://ero.ontario.ca/notice/013-5033.

Roger Suffling, Science Committee member,

Quetico Foundation